Welcome Email Sequence: 5 Emails for a One-Person Newsletter (Written Out)
A five-email welcome sequence for a small newsletter, every email written out, with when to send each one, when one welcome email is still enough, and what it costs to build in MailerLite and Kit.
In my post on the welcome email I actually send, I said a new newsletter only needs one welcome email. I still think that, and one email is still what this site sends.
But one email stops being enough in three situations, and if you’re in any of them, a short sequence will do more for you than a longer first email ever could. So I wrote out the five-email version I’d switch to. All five emails are below, with when to send each and what each one is for.
When one welcome email stops being enough
You promised a freebie on your signup form. The first email has to deliver it, and that leaves no room to introduce yourself properly. Splitting the jobs across two or three emails keeps each one short.
You plan to sell something. A course, a template pack, paid coaching, anything. If the first email a reader gets about money arrives cold three months in, it feels like a different newsletter. A sequence lets you mention it early, once, without pressure.
Readers keep asking the same question. If the replies to your welcome email keep circling one topic, that topic deserves its own email. It’s the cheapest content research you’ll ever get.
If none of those fit, stay with one email. Everything below will still be here when one of them does.
The sequence at a glance
| Send | Its job | Subject line | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Right after they confirm | Deliver what you promised, set the frequency | You’re in. Here’s what to expect |
| 2 | Day 2 | Give them your single most useful post | The one post I’d read first |
| 3 | Day 4 | Tell them why you started, briefly | Why I write this |
| 4 | Day 7 | Ask one question and invite a reply | Quick question for you |
| 5 | Day 10 | Mention the paid thing, or hand off to the regular newsletter | What happens from here |
Five emails over ten days. That’s close enough together that they still remember signing up, and far enough apart that it doesn’t feel like a flood. After email 5, they get the regular newsletter like everyone else.
Email 1: Right after they confirm
This is the welcome email from my earlier post, with one change: if you promised a freebie, the link goes first.
Hi,
Thanks for confirming. Here's the checklist I mentioned: [link]. It's yours to keep.
I'm [name], and I write [newsletter] on my own. You'll get one email when a new post goes up, and over the next ten days, a few short notes to help you get the most out of it.
Talk soon,
[name]
Why it’s built this way. The freebie is what they signed up for, so it comes before anything about you. The line about “a few short notes” is the important one. It tells them the next four emails are coming, so they don’t feel ambushed when email 2 shows up two days later.
Email 2: Day 2
Hi,
If you only read one thing I've written, I'd pick this: [post title and link].
It's the one readers mention most when they reply, and it covers [one sentence on what the reader gets from it].
[name]
Why it’s built this way. My single welcome email gives three links. In a sequence you have room to give one link per email, and one link gets more clicks than three, because the reader doesn’t have to choose. Pick the post that best shows what your newsletter does, not your newest one.
Email 3: Day 4
Hi,
Quick bit of background, since you've been getting my emails for a few days.
I started [newsletter] because [the problem you had, in one sentence]. I tried [the obvious fix] and it didn't work, because [the reason, in one sentence]. What I write here is what I wish I'd found back then.
That's it. Back to useful stuff next time.
[name]
Why it’s built this way. In the single-email version I left out the story completely, because one email can’t carry everything. Here it gets its own email, and it still stays short. The structure is a problem, a fix that didn’t work and why, and what you do now. The failed fix is the part that makes readers trust you, because it shows you’ve been where they are.
Email 4: Day 7
Hi,
You've been on the list for a week now, so I'd like to ask you something.
What's the one thing about [your topic] you're stuck on right now? Hit reply and tell me. One line is plenty. I read every answer, and the most common ones turn into posts.
[name]
Why it’s built this way. My single welcome email asks a question too, but on day one people barely know who you are. A week in, they’ve read a few emails and have a better reason to answer. “One line is plenty” lowers the effort, and “the most common ones turn into posts” tells them their answer goes somewhere.
Email 5: Day 10
This one has two versions. Use the first if you sell something, the second if you don’t yet.
If you sell something:
Hi,
This is the last of the welcome emails. From here you'll get one email when a new post goes up.
One more thing, so it never comes as a surprise: I also sell [product], which [what it does, in one sentence]. It's [price]. If it's not for you, ignore this, and you won't hear about it more than once a month.
[link]
[name]
If you don’t sell anything yet:
Hi,
This is the last of the welcome emails. From here you'll get one email when a new post goes up, usually [how often].
If there's a topic you'd like me to cover, my inbox is open. Just reply.
[name]
Why it’s built this way. The offer goes last, after four emails that gave something away. It’s mentioned once, with the price, and with a limit on how often it’ll come up. Saying the price upfront saves both of you time. And the “once a month” promise is one you have to keep, so only make it if you will.
What I’d leave out
A countdown or a discount that expires. It works on some lists, but on a newsletter that people joined for writing, it reads like a different sender took over.
More than one link per email. Email 1 is the exception if you’re delivering a freebie. Everywhere else, one link keeps each email doing one job.
Long emails. All five above run under 120 words. If an email needs more, it’s probably two emails, or a post.
What happens if you publish during the sequence
Say someone joins on Monday and you publish a new post on Wednesday. They’ll get email 2 of the sequence and your regular newsletter in the same week.
For a small list, I’d let that happen. Two emails in a week from someone they just signed up for is fine, and the new post is probably the most current thing you have. Just make sure your sequence emails don’t say “you’ll only hear from me once a week,” because this week that’s not true.
If your regular sends are daily, or close to it, it’s worth looking for a setting that holds new subscribers out of regular sends until the sequence ends. I haven’t set this up myself, so check your tool’s help pages for what it calls this.
Building it: MailerLite or Kit
Both tools can run this sequence. The difference is what it costs you, especially on the free plans.
| MailerLite | Kit | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan includes automated email sequences | Yes, up to 3 active automations with up to 5 steps each | No. Sequences and visual automations need a paid plan |
| Free plan subscriber limit | 250 | 10,000 |
| Paid plan you’d need for all five emails | Probably Comfort, from $12 a month, which allows 100 steps per automation (see below) | Creator, $33 a month at 1,000 subscribers, billed yearly |
| Free trial of the paid plan | Not mentioned on the pricing page | 14 days of Creator or Pro, no credit card to start |
Prices and limits are from each tool’s pricing page, checked November 2, 2026: MailerLite and Kit.
In MailerLite, the sequence is one automation: the trigger is “when subscriber joins a group,” then email 1, a delay, email 2, a delay, and so on. That’s the same automation I built for my single welcome email, with more steps added.
The catch is the step limit. MailerLite’s pricing page caps each automation at 5 steps on the free plan and 100 on the paid plans. Five emails with a wait between each is nine steps, if every wait counts as a step. I haven’t built the five-email version in my account yet, so I haven’t seen exactly how MailerLite counts them. If it counts the way I expect, the free plan fits a three-email version (email 1, wait, email 2, wait, email 3), and the full five needs the Comfort plan. For a three-email version, I’d keep emails 1, 2 and 5 and fold the question from email 4 into email 5.
In Kit, Kit’s pricing page describes the free plan as having no automated sequences. So on Kit, this sequence starts at the Creator plan. Kit’s free plan does deliver a freebie file automatically when someone signs up, but the welcome emails themselves need Creator.
Which one I’d pick. If you’re starting a newsletter with no budget, MailerLite’s free plan lets you start with a three-email version for $0, and moving to all five costs $12 a month. That low starting cost is why I use it. If you already know you’ll sell digital products and want a tool built around that, Kit’s 14-day trial is long enough to build this sequence and see how it feels before paying. I haven’t used Kit, so I can only tell you what the pricing page says. Try both editors with email 1 before you commit to either.
How to tell if it’s working
MailerLite shows opens and clicks for each email inside an automation. With a sequence, the number that matters is where people stop.
- Opens drop sharply at one email. The email before it probably gave them a reason to stop opening. Look at that one first.
- Email 2 gets the most clicks. That’s normal, since it’s the one built around a single link. If it doesn’t, try a different post.
- Email 4 gets replies. Count them in your inbox, since replies don’t show up in the reports. Even two or three replies from your first fifty subscribers tell you what to write next.
Give it at least fifty subscribers before changing anything. Five people’s behavior is mostly noise.
Before you build yours
Write email 1 first and send it to yourself. If you don’t have a freebie or anything to sell yet, stop there. You’re in the one-email situation, and my single welcome email template is the one to use.
If you haven’t picked a tool yet, I compared seven of them in the tools that design and send newsletters.